Posts Tagged 'Ukraine'

“We closed the doors, but it didn’t help. LGBT people in Russia have become extremists”

Guest post from Yaroslav Rasputin, Parni PLUS (Guys PLUS)

There’s a scared young man inside the cage that holds defendants in the Russian courts. Soon, he will be replaced by a woman from the same bar, and then they will both be taken to their cells. This cage will likely witness the first case of its kind in Russia, when the organizers of a drag show will be imprisoned for extremism.

Orenburg is a Russian city near the Ural Mountains that separate Europe and Asia. The values here are distinctly Russian: people on TV talk about how soldiers defend Russia from LGBT Ukrainians even as gay and lesbian people are served cocktails in a small nearby bar that seeks anonymity by forgoing a sign. It is known for sure that there are 15 wigs in the club: some are worn by drag queens, some are in the dressing room.

Over the last 10 years of heightened persecution of LGBT people in Russia, visitors have become accustomed to a simple rule: “Do whatever you want behind the closed doors!” Russian politicians made this promise over and over again while still adopting more and more severe laws.

Russian gay club regulars don’t like those who carry the Pride flag outside the closed doors. But if you follow the rules, you can dance safely, can’t you?

No, you can’t. And it’s not me who’s answering; that’s the answer you get from a policeman’s boot. There are new people at the bar. They don’t have any wigs or fake breasts. They wear uniforms, some have weapons, others have the stripes of the Russian Community of Orenburg, the city’s nationalist organization. This is a raid. There is a Russian word for “raid,” but oddly enough, the opponents of Western values prefer the English word, using it as they crack down on LGBT Russians.

They say lying on the floor face down for several hours is no fun. Stripped down to your underwear is even less so — to the extent that you no longer think about such stupid inconveniences as the several smartphone cameras recording this humiliation. In one of the videos from this raid, a man is dragged along the floor and asked to straighten up. He covers his head with his hands and presses his knees to his chest to protect himself against the blows to the most vulnerable places.

The blows were not captured on the video.

On November 30, 2023, the Supreme Court of Russia declared the “International LGBT Social Movement” to be “extremist.” There isn’t and there has never been such an organization, of course, but the decision states that it has divisions, coordinators, and participants in Russia. They are not named but are calculated: 40 organizations, 80 internet resources, and 281 “cell leaders.” The court does not say who these people are or what they do. But they are now prohibited from doing that, whatever that is.

What should they do? The court does not give any answer. Only the boot does.

I am reading this news from a safe distance. You are probably as well. In countries that have expressed concern about the new Russian repression, it is generally difficult to imagine that you can actually lie under a policeman’s boot just because you are a guy who wanted to drink and dance with another guy to good music. I left Russia not so long ago and still remember this fear. I really don’t want you to share my feelings — I pray you never feel this way.

Prague, Czech Republic – September 8, 2013: No gay propaganda beyond this line. Banner against the Russian anti gay laws in front of the Russian Embassy in Prague, Czech Republic.

The lives of LGBT people in Russia are in danger. For many years, Putin’s power divided us. He and his people used to say, “We are not violating your rights, but…” A new violation of rights would inevitably come after this “but”: do not approach children, do not appear on TV during the daytime, do not hold festivals, do not open your websites. And they always added, “Just do whatever you want behind the closed doors!”

We saw a succession of such statements, one after another. Some of us wanted to demand our rights and reverse this spiral. Others wanted them to just let us be in the hope that it wouldn’t get any worse. We were fighting with each other.

But there were no winners in the end.

When Russia launched a full-scale invasion of Ukraine, I felt really bad. The rallies I went to didn’t help anything or anybody. Nor did the antiwar graffiti and leaflets that I secretly made and distributed. But at least they were talked about. They were noticed and supported. I didn’t feel so lonely.

Almost immediately, Russian propagandists decided that Ukraine and LGBT people are basically the same thing. Finding Nazis in the occupied territories was difficult. Finding LGBT pamphlets was much easier. It turned out that Russian soldiers were fighting against the promotion of homosexuality and “transgenderism.”

Ukraine had no idea it was promoting anything like that. The Russian opposition was afraid of losing its audience and preferred to keep silent.

For the enemy not to attack from the rear, Russian politicians banned the so-called “LGBT propaganda.” By that time, Ekaterina Mizulina, the head of the Safe Internet League, had already attacked me. She published my phone number on the Internet that she was supposed to be making safe and secure. This safety was obviously not for the benefit of people like me, so I fled the country. But Russia remained with me, in my head and in my news feed.

The following summer, they banned gender transition. They said, as always, it was about the worried parents. “Transgender people brainwash our children!” they declared on TV.

But we are your children, too.

To leave no doubt, they “caught” two people setting fire to military registration and enlistment offices. One of them said on camera that she was a transgender woman. With her, she had some documents allegedly signed by the Ukrainian Armed Forces and the Free Russia Legion fighting on the Ukraine side. And, for some reason, a butt plug. The second was a transgender man who, according to TV reports, worked for OVD-Info, a human rights organization that had already been persecuted by the authorities.

Human rights activists went looking for these people. OVD-Info also looked for the “employee” of theirs who they had never heard of before. With no luck. Nor were there any trials of these two individuals. The Russian government, which accuses the West of “fakes,” turned out to be a master of producing them itself.

But these stories served their purpose, as it later became clear. In the fall of 2023, the Ministry of Justice, having collected such “irrefutable” evidence, demanded that we all be recognized as extremists. The Supreme Court agreed.

The police raid on the Pose club in Orenburg was not the first. There were dozens of them throughout the country. Some clubs’ party photos were deemed to be “LGBT propaganda.” Some clubs closed down; others tried to pretend to be straight.

But putting the manager and the art director of an LGBT bar in prison for 10 years is a brand-new step in the history of Russia.

When I read news about how random people — and even people I know — are detained for connections with “extremists,” I feel bad. When I see these people in a cage who are about to be imprisoned for 10 years for working in a club and buying wigs for drag queens, I am horrified.

A Russian prison is a terrible place for anyone. But if the average prisoner is lucky enough to go unnoticed, it’s open season on those jailed for waving the rainbow flag. And the prison administration will never interfere with the rape and torture of those LGBT prisoners. I’m sick when I think about it, so forgive me, I won’t delve into this much.

Instead, I write to my friends still in Russia, asking, “Goodness, how are you?”

“It’s okay, we’re already getting used to it,” they answer.

And they keep on dancing.

The LGBT community can the toughest of times. We have seen this all through history: we survived medieval prisons, Nazi camps, and Soviet gulags. We liberated Christopher Street in the USA, lived through the HIV/AIDS epidemic, rescued those convicted of sodomy in Russia, and achieved equal rights in Orthodox Greece. We went through all this with unimaginable sacrifices, but after each blow, those of us who were able to rise joined their hands again and again.

The Russian LGBT community needs global help today more than ever. Please don’t turn your backs on us.

Samara, Russia – May 5, 2018: Police officers block an Leningradskaya street during an opposition protest rally ahead of President Vladimir Putin’s inauguration ceremony

Happy International Women’s Day!

(March 8, 2024) Today, International Women’s Day, we’re excited to feature a handful of some of the fabulous and fierce lesbian, bisexual, trans, queer, and allied women working all around the world for justice broadly and for LBTQ+ women in particular.

Some are working for legal gender recognition, marriage equality, and sexual liberation; others are combating gender-based violence and discrimination and organizing for women- and queer-inclusive humanitarian relief. Their methods, goals, and contexts vary, but they all share extraordinary passion, skill, and dedication to feminist and queer inclusion and empowerment.

So without further ado, let’s celebrate these and all LBTQ+ women working to make the world a better place!

.  

MANISHA DHAKAL, Executive Director, Blue Diamond Society (Nepal)

Active in Nepal’s LGBTQI+ movement since 2001, Manisha Dhakal has worked on projects spanning HIV/AIDS, human rights activism, constitutional campaigns, advocacy, capacity building, academic research, LGBTQI+ child rights, and more. The first transgender woman in Nepal’s Country Coordinating Mechanism for the Global Fund, Manisha is currently the Executive Director of Blue Diamond Society (BDS), the country’s pioneering LGBTQI+ rights organization, as well as the President of Federation of Sexual and Gender Minorities of Nepal.  

Top Advocacy Priorities: Bridging the gap between the legal rights for LGBTQI+ people in Nepal and their implementation, such as for legal gender recognition and marriage equality.

BUKOLA LANDIS-AINA, Executive Director, Q Christian Fellowship (United States)

Bukola Landis-Aina is a first-generation Nigerian-American who is the Executive Director of Q Christian Fellowship, an organization that cultivates radical belonging for LGBTQI+ Christians and allies through a commitment to growth, community, and relational justice. Bukola is also a patent attorney, having studied Chemical Engineering at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and law at New York University. Additionally, she is ordained as a deacon. Bukola can often be found engaging in competitive sports, skiing, mentoring high school students, bringing people together, baking a cake, hosting weary travelers, and planning her next getaway with her wife and two little ones.

Top Advocacy Priorities: The vision that inspires Bukola in her work is to lead a community that prophetically models a world where all LGBTQI+ people are fully loved by family, church, and community, and Christians worldwide live up to their calling to be instruments of grace and defenders of the outcasts.

CAROL MUDZENGI, Programmes and Fundraising Officer, Voice of the Voiceless (Zimbabwe)

Carol is a queer African feminist, artist, and healing justice activist who cares deeply about decoloniality as a tool for mental well-being and collective wellness. Carol believes in trauma-informed holistic well-being with the key objective being collective care and love. She advocates for inclusion of LBQT+ persons in Zimbabwe, now with the Voice of the Voiceless collective, and has been active as an LGBTQI+ activist in various capacities for over 10 years. Carol is always seeking innovation in how queer identifying individuals can interrogate intersectionality with other struggles and build alliances with other movements.

Top Advocacy Priorities: Feminist healing justice as a catalyst for all other forms of justice to be attained.

TIFFANY KAGURE MUGO, Curator, HOLA Africa (South Africa)

Tiffany Kagure Mugo is the curator of HOLA Africa, a Pan-African sex-positive digital platform that focuses sex and sexuality on the continent through archiving stories, knowledge production and edutainment, digital community building and creating spaces that deal with safe sex and pleasure and other aspects of the politics and presence of sexuality. She hosts the sex and relationship podcast, Basically Life, and is a TED speaker. She is the author of Quirky Quick Guide To Having Great Sex, and she curated the anthology, Touch: Sex, Sexuality and Sensuality.

Top Advocacy Priorities: Bodily and sexual autonomy 

NORA NORALLA, Executive Director, Cairo 52 Legal Research Institute (Egypt)

Nora Noralla is an Egyptian human rights researcher and consultant. She is currently the Executive Director of Cairo 52 Legal Research Institute and a non-resident fellow at The Tahrir Institute for Middle East Policy. Her work focuses mainly on digital rights, sexual and bodily freedoms, LGBTQ+ rights, and Islamic Sharia from an intersectional queer feminist perspective. Her engagement with the human rights field started in the wake of the 25th of January revolution in Egypt. She has worked with different NGOs, including Human Rights Watch, Article 19, and the Berkman Klein Center for Internet and Society at Harvard University.

Top Advocacy Priorities: It is essential to identify new entry points for advancing LGBTQI+ rights in challenging contexts, such as the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region. Basic fundamental human rights, including the right to health and legal gender recognition for transgender and intersex individuals, can be attained through coordinated strategic litigation efforts. These efforts can exert pressure on MENA governments to ensure these rights, thus serving as crucial entry points for LGBTQI+ advocacy.

OLENA SHEVCHENKO, Chair, Insight (Ukraine)

A long-term advocate for LGBTQI+ and women’s rights in Europe & Central Asia, Olena Shevchenko founded Insight in 2007 to organize in support of the LGBTQI+ community in her native Ukraine. Since Russia’s brutal invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, Olena has been at the forefront of establishing shelters and safe houses for LGBTQI+ Ukrainians fleeing the war, of providing food and other emergency supplies to women and LGBTQI+ people, and of advocating for LGBTQI+ inclusion in the humanitarian response to the crisis. For her work, TIME recognized Olena as one of its “Women of the Year” in early 2023.

Top Advocacy Priorities: Implementation of the Istanbul Convention (on preventing and combating violence against women and domestic violence); passage of the civil partnership law for LGBTQI+ people in Ukraine.

DRAGANA TODOROVIC, Executive Director, EL*C (Serbia)

Dragana Todorović is the scandalously efficient Executive Co-Director of EL*C, the EuroCentralAsian Lesbian* Community. With an unparalleled passion for the lesbian movement and an entrepreneurial spirit that doesn’t take “impossible” for an answer, Dragana (re)defines the limits of the lesbian skies, drawing from a robust and eclectic experience combining the private sector, governmental institutions, and national and regional NGOs. This fierce Yugoslavian lesbian is notably the instigator of the Balkan LGBTI network, ERA, which she led for seven years as its Executive Co-Director. A multi-hyphenated and visionary character, her numerous talents stop at drafting her own bio, which she delegates blindly to her lover.

Top Advocacy Priorities: Advocating for the adoption of the LBQ Resolution by the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, which would be the first-ever international policy instrument to specifically address all forms of discrimination and violence faced by LBQ women; Lobbying for LBQ-inclusive implementation and monitoring of the Istanbul Convention, to ensure that the systems of protection, access to justice and assistance are effective for all women by adopting an intersectional approach, considering the additional obstacles faced by women from marginalized groups.

23 Victories to Celebrate for Pride 2023

As Pride Month comes to a close, we thought we’d take a moment to look back at some of the victories we’ve seen in the movement for global LGBTQI+ human rights over the past year:

Decriminalization

1. Five more countries have struck down discriminatory colonial-era laws that criminalized homosexuality, including three Caribbean countries — Antigua and Barbuda, Barbados, and St. Kitts and Nevis  — plus Singapore and the Cook Islands.

2. After last year’s historic ruling CEDAW ruling that Sri Lanka breached the rights of pioneering lesbian activist Rosanna Flamer-Caldera, Colombo has taken key steps towards decriminalizing homosexuality in the South Asian island country.

3. To the surprise of many, Pope Francis spoke out against laws criminalizing homosexuality.

Marriage Equality & Family Recognition

4. In December, President Biden signed the Respect for Marriage Act after Congress passed the law enshrining the rights to same-sex marriage equality and interracial marriage into law.

5. Just last week, Estonia became the first former Soviet republic to introduce marriage equality. This comes after victories over the past year in Mexico, Cuba, Slovenia, Switzerland,and Andorra extending the equal right to marriage to same-sex couples.

6. Several Asian countries took important steps towards marriage equality this past year —  whether through elections or court rulings — including Japan, South Korea, Thailand, and just as we went to press, Nepal.

7. Other victories for LGBTQI+ families included Taiwan’s legislature approving adoption rights for same-sex parents; Bolivia’s highest court recognizing civil unions; Namibia’s Supreme Court recognizing the rights same-sex couples married abroad; and Nepal’s Supreme Court likewise recognizing the foreign spouse of a Nepali citizen married overseas.

Transgender Rights & Legal Gender Recognition

8. In February, Spain passed a landmark legal gender recognition law allowing transgender people to change their gender marker on official documents based solely on their self-identification. In April, Vietnam took major steps in the same direction.

9. Earlier this month, U.S. federal judges struck down Arkansas’s ban on gender-affirming care for minors and Tennessee’s ban on drag shows on core constitutional grounds. And just yesterday, federal judges similarly blocked portions of bans on gender-affirming care for minors from going into effect in Kentucky and Tennessee.

Ending Involuntary and Coercive Medical and Psychological Anti-LGBTQI+ Practices

10. Greece and Kenya took major steps to protect intersex children from medically unnecessary “sex normalization” surgeries.

11. Spain, Iceland, and Cyprus joined the list of countries of countries that ban so-called “conversion therapy” practices — a list that also includes Canada, France, Malta, and (for minors only) Germany, Greece, and New Zealand.

12. Following President Biden’s Pride Month Executive Order last year, the State Department recently rolled out the U.S. government’s action plan to globally combat these so-called “conversion therapy” practices.

13. Vietnam officially adopted the positions that same-sex attraction and transgender status are not mental health disorders, bringing the nation in line with global health and human rights standards.

Rights and Resistance

14. In February, Kenya’s high court ruled in favor of the National Gay and Lesbian Human Rights Commission, ending its decade-long battle for official recognition. And just this month, Eswatini’s Supreme Court similarly ruled that denying LGBTQI+ organizations the right to register is discriminatory and unconstitutional

15. In recognition of her extraordinary advocacy for LGBTQI+ rights in war-torn Ukraine, TIME named Olena Shevchenko, leader of the Insight NGO, as one of its Women of the Year.

16. Activists such as Aleksandr Voronov have continued to promote social, legal, and health services for LGBTQI+ Russians, and a free civil society more generally, despite being forced to leave their homeland.

17. Tens of thousands of people marched in the Warsaw Pride parade a week ago in defiance of the right-wing government. This comes after yet another court ruled in favor of activists protesting the so-called “LGBT-free zones” declared by many Polish cities and towns.

Multilateral Cooperation to Promote LGBTQI+ Human Rights

18. In advance of May’s G7 summit in Hiroshima, Japanese LGBTQI+ activists hosted their international counterparts in the first-ever meeting of the “Pride 7,” or P7, to promote both domestic LGBTQI+ rights and coordination by the largest alliance of democratic industrial economies to promote LGBTQI+ human rights globally. This led to the passage of Japan’s first LGBTQI+ rights law.

19. The list of countries with ambassador-level officials promoting global LGBTQI+ human rights has grown to five: Argentina, France, Italy, the United Kingdom, and the United States. (Brazil and Germany also have high-level political appointees promoting internal LGBTQI+ rights.)

20. 50,000 people marched across the iconic Sydney Harbor Bridge as part of World Pride ’23 celebrations, a landmark event promoting LGBTQI+ human rights across Asia and the Pacific. And mark your calendars for World Pride ’25 in Washington, D.C.!

21. At World Pride, Australia announced its increased contribution to the Global Equality Fund. The Global Equality Fund, with the support of nearly twenty countries plus numerous private sector partners, has now distributed more than $100 million to promote LGBTQI+ civil society and protect LGBTQI+ human rights defenders in its ten years of operating. Earlier this spring, Spain became the 18th member of GEF, and just this week, New Zealand became #19.

22. USAID launched the Rainbow Fund, an initiative through which U.S. missions overseas integrate LGBTQI+ considerations into a broad range of sectors, including economic empowerment, education, health services, food security, and anti-corruption programs. USAID also launched the Alliance for Global Equality, a public-private partnership to promote LGBTQI+ community-based groups, build networks for LGBTQI+ workplace and social inclusion, and support leadership development in service of strengthening democracy. The State Department launched the Global LGBTQI+ Inclusive Democracy and Empowerment (GLIDE) initiative to support LGBTQI+ participation in democratic institutions.

23. Victor Madrigal-Borloz is just now completing his highly successful final term as the United Nations Independent Expert on Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity, promoting LGBTQI+ human rights all over the world and institutionalizing SOGIESC work within U.N. institutions. The LGBTI Core Group, an alliance of U.N. members dedicated to advancing LGBTQI+ human rights through the United Nations, welcomed six new members: Denmark, the Dominican Republic, Finland, Honduras, Ireland, and Timor Leste.

Yes, we know that some of these steps are partial victories, whether we’re looking at the limits of the U.S. Respect for Marriage Act, the watered-down compromise bill passed by the Japanese Diet, the ban on marriage equality written into Singapore’s repeal of Section 377A, or Pope Francis’s continued reference to homosexuality as “sin.” And none of these steps forward mitigate the horrors of the vicious anti-LGBTQI+ laws that have been passed recently in U.S. states and around the world, the transphobic hysteria whipped up by cynical politicians, the war still raging in Ukraine, or the violence endured and the fears experienced by our communities in too many parts of the world.

We know all that; we, and many of you, work day in and day out on those issues, and we never forget that. We keep up our advocacy to make U.S. foreign policy more LGBTQI+-inclusive, to strengthen LGBTQI+ civil society around the world, and to show that democracy and human rights for all really mean for all. Rights are hard-fought by our communities and by fearless advocates in all countries. Justice is achieved step by step, small victory after small victory.

As we wind down June, as we keep our eye on bending the arc of history towards justice, it’s important to take a moment to celebrate our victories and remember what we have indeed accomplished. After all, the movement for LGBTQI+ human rights is one that continues all year round, and that’s something to be proud of.

World Refugee Day: Hope Away From Home

Refugees and immigrants looking for a new life. Column of migrants near the state borders. Fence and barbed wire. Surveillance, supervised. Abandon their lands for a better future. 3d render. Silhouette

Today, June 20, marks World Refugee Day when we celebrate the resilience and courage of those people forced to flee their home due to persecution, conflict, climate change, and other catastrophic crises.

While both the U.S. and global mechanisms of refuge, migration, and asylum are badly broken for all in flight, LGBTQI+ refugees escaping homophobia and transphobia along with these other threats face especially grave dangers — not only in their home countries but from some transit countries, from fellow refugees, and from international refugee systems often unable and sometimes unwilling to address the particular risks facing LGBTQI+ refugees.

Globally, there are more than 108 million forcibly displaced persons, according to the UNHCR, the U.N. Refugee Agency. That’s up more than 250% in the last ten years. Put another way, if all those refugees made up a single country, that country would rank 13th in population in the world, coming in just after Mexico, Japan, and the Philippines.

We don’t have reliable figures for how many LGBTQI+ refugees there are, as U.S. and international refugee agencies do not have systems in place to consistently track this data. In some cases, that speaks to officials not taking seriously the specific dangers facing LGBTQI+ refugees; in other cases, well-intentioned, legitimate concerns about the safety facing LGBTQI+ refugees become the grounds for not taking any action at all.

But we do know, for example, that one organization alone, Rainbow Railroad, received nearly 10,000 inquiries in 2022 regarding possible emergency resettlement and related services for LGBTQI+ refugees. Since the beginning of 2023, Rainbow Railroad has received yet another 4100+ such inquiries.

We know that hundreds of LGBTQI+ individuals in the Kakuma refugee camp in northwestern Kenya live in fear of being attacked or even killed, with many of them having survived physical and sexual violence, according to a report last month from Amnesty International and the National Gay and Lesbian Human Rights Commission (NGLHRC) of Kenya.

As Irungu Houghton, Amnesty International Kenya’s Executive Director, explained, “Despite a constitution that protects life and dignity for all, LGBTI asylum seekers suffer discrimination as well as homophobic and transphobic attitudes from government officials, the police and other service providers. This is often reflected in delays to the processing of their asylum claims, harassment, violent homophobic attacks, threats, and intimidation, and extremely limited opportunities for local integration or third-country resettlement.”

Speaking to the Washington Blade last week, Kieynan Gant described how “We are often forced to hide our true selves and live in isolation, unable to express ourselves or form meaningful relationships. Some have even been forced into marriages with people of the opposite sex against their will. … Our efforts [to raise awareness of these issues and demand better treatment for LGBTQI+ refugees] have been met with resistance and hostility from some of the other refugees in the camp who view our sexuality as a threat to their cultural and religious values.”

In recent years, some of the LGBTQI+ refugees in Kenya originally fled from Uganda. The recent passage of Uganda’s horrific Anti-Homosexuality Act has generated a sharp surge in LGBTQI+ refugees fleeing their country, with Rainbow Railroad receiving nearly 500 requests for help from Ugandans even before President Museveni signed the bill into law late last month.

The queer refugee crisis is hardly limited to East Africa. We continue to see a steady stream of LGBTQI+ people fleeing Afghanistan, Ukraine, Syria, the Caribbean, and other regions torn by war, extremist regimes, and pervasive homophobia and transphobia. LGBTQI+ Ukrainians fleeing the Russian war have encountered discrimination and harassment upon arriving in Poland and other neighboring countries, with same-sex couples and transgender refugees facing especially heightened risk for hostile treatment.

Likewise, Rainbow Railroad, Amnesty International, and other CGE members receive regular requests for emergency resettlement from LGBTQI+ Afghans sheltering in Pakistan, where their experiences illustrate the homophobia and transphobia that so many queer refugees face in transit countries.

In today’s World Refugee Day statement from the White House, President Biden reiterated his Administration’s promise to rebuild the U.S. Refugee Admissions Program and to welcome 125,000 refugees next year. So far, however, the United States has only admitted just under 32,000 refugees this year, a pace well under the White House’s ambitious goals.

We call on Washington to follow in Ottawa’s lead and establish a direct referral program comparable to the landmark partnership just announced between Rainbow Railroad and the Canadian government. The United States needs to enable organizations like Rainbow Railroad that have full competency in LGBTQI+ refugee issues to refer such at-risk individuals for resettlement here.

We further applaud the U.S. government’s rollout of the Welcome Corps private sponsorship program, and we strongly encourage the various government agencies involved in resettlement work to ensure that at-risk LGBTQI+ refugees are indeed referred to approved private sponsorship organizations such as Rainbow Railroad.

This year’s theme for World Refugee Day is “Hope Away From Home: A World Where Refugees Are Always Included.” This must, of course, include all refugees, regardless of sexual orientation or gender identity. And we do see hope amidst this challenging work, as in the story of Ahmed, a bisexual refugee in Kenya. Ahmed, a bisexual refugee, has been working with ORAM — like Rainbow Railroad and Amnesty International, ORAM is a CGE member organization working to support LGBTQI+ refugees. After fleeing death threats in his native country and then experiencing discrimination in Jordan, his first transit country, Ahmed is now taking part in ORAM’s economic empowerment program in Kenya. With seed funding from ORAM, Ahmed launched a small business charging mobile devices, allowing him to get back on his feet and to support other LGBTQI+ refugees.

While U.S. and international refugee systems need comprehensive, LGBTQI+-inclusive reforms and funding, we do want to take a moment to celebrate Ahmed’s resilience and that of all queer refugees who have found safety and security, even as we work together to make sure that hope away from home is a reality, not just a dream, for so many more.

Coming Out in Putin’s Russia: A Conversation with Aleksandr Voronov

We recently had the chance to spend some time with Russian LGBTQI+ activist Aleksandr Voronov on his visit to Washington, D.C. in early May. Aleksandr — Alex, to his American friends — is the Executive Director of Coming Out, an NGO that provides legal, psychological, and other direct services to Russia’s LGBTQI+ community. Coming Out also conducts research on Russian attitudes on sexual orientation and gender identity; supports families and friends of Russian LGBTQI+ community members; and builds working partnerships with allies in the country’s legal, business, media, mental health, and other professional spaces.

Broadly speaking, Alex explained, Coming Out works to make everyday life better for LGBTQI+ Russians, to identify access points to change in Russian society and culture, and to find allies and make them into agents of change, all on the road to equality.

Alex, who has been based in Vilnius, Lithuania, since shortly after Vladimir Putin ordered the invasion of Ukraine last year, shared his story of joining Coming Out in early 2020. A social worker in Saint Petersburg working with families, people living with HIV, and unhoused persons, Alex was looking for a career change right as Coming Out was hiring for its brand-new position of Monitoring and Advocacy Officer. He came on board at the beginning of April 2020, just as Russia was implementing COVID-19 lockdowns.

For the Saint Petersburg-based organization, this turned out to be an unexpected blessing, as Coming Out shifted to online operations — allowing it to serve the LGBTQI+ community across Russia’s eleven time zones, not just in its home city. This shift allowed Coming Out to not only to survive but to grow, even as Russian authorities declared the NGO to be a “foreign agent” and then as Coming Out’s leadership left the country following the beginning of the Ukraine War. As Alex noted, yes, being labeled as a “foreign agent” led some Russians to stop volunteering with Coming Out, some businesses and other partners to end their collaborations with the organization. But Alex — who was promoted to serve as Executive Director in late 2021, right before the “foreign agent” ruling came down — and his leadership team steered Coming Out through this pair of existential crises to survival and expansion of its services, even from outside Russia’s borders.

As one might expect, the Ukraine War and the series of homophobic and transphobic laws pushed from the Kremlin have made life challenging for Russia’s LGBTQI+ community — though not always in ways the West might expect.

The escalating mobilization for a war originally planned to take just a few days carries particular implications for the LGBTQI+ community, notably in prohibiting citizens identified as male on official documents from leaving the country. At the same time, the Russian state is also proposing to make it more difficult for citizens to officially change their gender markers on such documents. While the implementation of the new policy is just kicking in, it may very well add to wartime challenges facing transgender Russians, whose access to gender-affirming hormone therapy has been disrupted by the conflict and whose ongoing economic marginalization has only escalated due to the state of the Russian war economy. And a new bill in the Russian parliament may also shut down private centers for transition-related care, making it even more difficult, if not impossible, for many transgender Russians to seek ongoing treatment and transition support.

For Vladimir Putin, the war in Ukraine and his country’s decade-long assault on LGBTQ rights are two sides of the same coin,” argues Foreign Policy analyst Amy Mackinnon. “Scapegoated in the state media and portrayed as agents of Western influence, Russia’s queer community was the canary in the coal mine of the wider offensive against the West that was to follow when Putin returned to the presidency in 2012.” Both the original 2013 anti-LGBTQ “propaganda” law and the expanded law passed late last year point to the importance of this tool in the arsenal Putin is wielding both against the West and the against the very concepts of human rights and civil society.

In an op-ed last week, Graeme Reid, Director of Human Rights Watch’s LGBT Rights Program, likewise framed the expanded “propaganda” law as a move “to consolidate conservative support at home and position Russia as the defender of ‘traditional values’, in opposition to ‘the west’.” The 2013 law itself “has been at the heart of Russia’s domestic politics and foreign engagements — a symbol of its wholesale rejection of universal human rights. Its extension is but one further step in representing LGBT+ rights as a foreign threat and a Trojan-horse ‘enemy within’,” Reid argues. Reid and others have long noted how Putin has this rhetoric to restore Russia’s influence in the traditional Soviet sphere of influence, from Viktor Orban’s Hungary and Duda’s Poland to the authoritarian regimes of Central Asia. Now, Russia is exporting both military helicopters and anti-LGBTQI+ legislation to Uganda, among other partners in the war on democracy and human rights.

Prague, Czech Republic – September 8, 2013: No gay propaganda beyond this line. Banner against the Russian anti gay laws in front of the Russian Embassy in Prague, Czech Republic.

For Alex, the importance of the anti-propaganda laws at home lies less in their direct prosecution, as that has been relatively infrequent and mostly haphazard. Instead, as documented by the recent research Coming Out conducted in partnership with Sphere, another LGBTQI+ Russian organization, the major impacts of the laws for everyday citizens are psychological stress and self-censorship. That is, the fear of bringing up LGBTQI+ issues is real. And the infrequent, almost arbitrary use of the law in unpredictable ways magnifies the psychological stress, because it’s not easy to predict when the government will bring charges. This keeps the community on edge, and that’s the point.

From the outside, the Russian system looks more like a system than it actually is. What Russians face is repressive but not predictably so, and that uncertainty adds greatly to the daily stress. Indeed, the randomness of how anti-LGBTQI+ laws are used is central to the repression: when you might or might not be punished for your actions, there’s no way to plan, and the tendency, Alex explained, is to not say anything, not share anything on social media, out of an understandable abundance of caution. Also, while some dating apps have left Russia, there hasn’t yet been a full-scale push by the authorities to close LGBTQI+ bars and other commercial venues — but that potential loss of critical social space could very well still happen. Indeed, indications suggest that’s coming.

One particular danger that the anti-propaganda laws pose for LGBTQI+ Russians and their allies is grounded in police corruption. For police officers trying to meet quotas of cases prosecuted — whether to get more money, a promotion, or more stars on their uniform — winning a conviction for propaganda is far easier than investigating and prosecuting a case for murder or burglary, for example. Rather than conducting an extensive investigation, winning a propaganda conviction only requires going online, finding and saving a questionable post, and showing it to the court.

For Alex, there’s an opportunity in the general disinterest in LGBTQI+ issues on the part of Russians at large. As Coming Out’s research has shown, Russians don’t necessarily believe in their current political system, but — as they focus on paying their rent, making ends meet, and staying out of poverty — they want to fit in and survive. This harkens back to life under the oppressive Soviet system. Stability and order are as central to Russian political culture as freedom and liberty are in American politics. So, as Alex explained, if the state warns that Westerners with “non-traditional values” (a phrase whose power lies in its vagueness) are endangering that stability, to upset the “don’t ask, don’t tell” order of daily life, that’s an effective message.

Coming Out’s research also suggests that though the anti-propaganda laws have been crushing for activism in Russia, along with the brutal state crackdown on all dissent since the outbreak of the war, LGBTQI+ Russians are not experiencing homophobia as a constant factor in their everyday lives. In Saint Petersburg and Moscow, being queer is becoming normalized, especially for younger people (although LGBTQI+ people are far less likely to feel safe coming out in other parts of the country). “So, while activism isn’t really happening right now, people are living their lives,” Alex noted.

As we wound down our conversation, Alex brought up the urgency of not conflating the Russian people with the Russian government. He pointed to the large protests last year — and to the violence and cruelty of the state in punishing demonstrators — as evidence that many Russians would like to change the situation they face but don’t currently have to tools to do so. The lack of independent media also remains a key factor – though, as Alex reminded me, the American example shows that access to a broad range of viewpoints doesn’t foreclose support for authoritarian politicians.

As Alex returns to Vilnius, as the Coming Out team continues to advocate for LGBTQI+ Russians, and as Russia’s war continues in Ukraine with no end in sight, the fight against the various repressive tactics of authoritarianism includes supporting our LGBTQI+ colleagues working in Russia and elsewhere around the world on the frontlines of the fight for democracy.  The fight for LGBTQI+ rights is a fight for democracy and free civil society, and there is no clearer example of that than Russia.

Pride March Support Statement by Ambassador John F. Tefft

Amb. John Tefft, UkraineMarch 2012- As Ambassador of the United States of America in Kyiv, I would like to express my support and the support of my country to all those who will participate in the first ever Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender (LGBT) Pride March in Ukraine on May 20, 2012.  It saddens me to note that in many parts of the world, members of the LGBT community continue to suffer violence, discrimination, or persecution because of their sexual orientation or gender identity.  As Secretary of State Clinton states, “gay rights are human rights, and human rights are gay rights,” and by embracing diversity, promoting tolerance and fighting prejudice and discrimination, we strive to build a world where everyone can enjoy his or her fundamental human rights.

I would like to convey my appreciation to the organizers of the Kyiv Pride March, and I hope that many people, both gay and straight, will join us in this cause.  I wish everyone a successful and peaceful celebration.


Stay Informed

Subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 283 other subscribers

Categories

Archives